How Should A Christian Vote
Sunday After Pentecost, Year ~ Off Lectionary, Philippians 2:1-11
October 26, 2008 ~ Kenwood UMC
I can still remember the first presidential election I voted in. It was 1976, I was six years old and in the first grade at Crestwood Elementary School in Chesterfield County. The school had a mock election that fall when Jimmy Carter was running against Gerald Ford. Now, I cast my vote very carefully and thoughtfully. I weighed the options and I made an informed decision to vote for Gerald Ford. What decided my vote? My parents, perhaps? No. My understanding of the issues? Not hardly. My faith? Nope. What made my decision was that my best friend at the time was named Christie Ford, and so I decided that if her character was good enough to be my best friend, his character was good enough to be President of the United States.
We can’t look at this just as humorous—some of the same kind of logic is at work in politics today. And as responsible, thoughtful people we want to make a choice that matters, that is based on something. And as Christians, we also want to make a choice which is in line with our faith. But how? What are the criteria we should use?
Well, we might initially say, we can look at a candidate and if they are a Christian, we should vote for them. A candidate’s faith certainly plays an important role in politics today—we don’t have to look any farther than President Bush, or Mike Huckabee, or Mitt Romney or Hillary Clinton or Barak Obama to discover that faith has become an issue. But what kind of an issue should a candidate’s personal faith be—should that be the deciding factor in our vote?
I would argue that it should not—because the qualifications for being the President of the United States are not primarily about faith—they are about leadership, and judgment and wisdom and lots of other things, but not primarily faith. And we all know that just because a person says they are a Christian, or just because a person says they attend church, that doesn’t mean that we understand them. They might not profess the same kind of Christian values that we do. They might, for instance, think very differently about whether the communion table is open—some churches don’t invite everyone to the table. What kind of relevance does that have? Well, it has relevance for political issues which deal with hospitality, such as immigration issues.
We also can’t issue vote on things such as abortion or the death penalty, and say, well, here is the Christian perspective on these issues, so I vote with the candidate who shares that perspective. These kinds of issues are complicated, and there are faithful believers on all sides of social issues such as this. So, again, it is not as simple as saying, well, this candidate believes the “Christian” thing on this issue, so I’ll vote for him or her.
So I don’t think figuring out how to vote is as simple as saying, OK, here’s the candidate who is the best Christian, I’ll vote for them. And that’s why I think it’s not helpful for me, as your pastor, to pass some sort of judgment on candidates, and tell you who to vote for. I think we have to dig deeper.
And when we dig deeper, I think we have to look at scripture and at the values we hold as followers of Jesus, and let those values guide our decision making. And the baseline value of Jesus, as it is presented in the scripture from Philippians that we read this morning, is humility.
What exactly is humility? Humility is putting others first. Humility is realizing it isn’t all about me—or us. Humility means our motivation for something is not selfish conceit or ambition—instead our motivation for doing something is that it will make the world a better place for others. Humility, as Jesus lived it, means doing what he promised to do early in his ministry as he read the scroll of the prophet Isaiah in the temple in his hometown of Nazareth. It is recorded in the 4th chapter of Luke that Jesus promises to offer good news to the poor, pardon the prisoners, set the oppressed free, and offer sight to the blind.
Now, these are not political promises which will make one popular. When we follow in Jesus’ footsteps and look out for the interests of those who are oppressed and held captive, it is difficult to win an election. Why? Because when someone who is relatively stable asks the question, “what are you going to do for me” the honest answer is—not much. But the humble leader can help us realize that it isn’t about me—it is about us, about our world, about how we live together as brothers and sisters.
Now, let me be clear—we are not looking for a Messiah here. We’re not voting for a Messiah. But if we are Christians, when we vote, we should cast our vote for those who look out for the least, the last and the lost. When we are Christians and we vote, we don’t look only at what policies the candidates stand for that will make our lives better—we need to look at others’ lives as well. We need to embrace the humility of our Savior and look beyond ourselves. And when we do that, we will find the candidates who are better able to look beyond themselves. And that is how I believe we can most responsibly cast our vote as Christians.